You have to love the Roaming Buffalo in the University area of Denver a few miles south of downtown.
The owners and staff are lovely people who really care about their work. They seem to make everything from scratch, including flavored potato chips (sea salt or green chile and white cheddar), and they have an unusual menu. They barbecue lamb — both shoulder and shank — and home-made cheese and jalapeño sausages, in addition to the more common brisket, pork and (it’s Colorado) buffalo.
We ordered a plate with lamb shoulder, pork and buffalo ribs (they were out of the jalapeño cheddar sausage, alas) with potato salad and cole slaw. A corn muffin came with the plate.
That’s the lamb in the foreground, the lighter pork in the back flanked by the chunky buffalo ribs.
The lamb was pretty good. It had a soft smoky flavor and a good lamb taste. Like the brisket, it was moist and tender without being mushy. The pork suffered, as much pork suffers, from the failure to use hickory and the absence of a pit. The buffalo ribs were very lean, which is not what ribs should be. They have two sauces, one regular and one spicy, and a third home-made tabasco- or Texas Pete-type sauce. The spicy sauce was, in fact, too spicy for Nancy. who has a pretty strong tolerance for peppers, but I preferred it. Both sauces were pretty good, however, and complemented the meats. The buffalo, being lean, really benefited from the sauce.
The potato salad was good and the cole slaw was very good, with parsley and sweet peppers. There also was strawberry-jalapeno jam on the table and a corn muffin to go with it. Pretty good, but I would have liked more jalapeño; or it could be reworked with cayenne. We split a banana pudding which was pretty good.
The real limitation on the Roaming Buffalo is its method of cooking — the dread box smoker that infests so many urban barbecue places outside the South.
The staff graciously demonstrated the smoker and explained the use of wood pellets, bless their hearts. It’s a mix of oak and pecan if I recall (but still wood pellets) — that the smoker itself adds gradually. The benefit of a box smoker is that it is hard not to have moist meat, but that comes at the sacrifice of a proper char and problems with matching the wood to the meat; thus, no hickory for the pork. Compare, for example, the earlier posts on Bob Syke’s or Miss Myra’s, both in Alabama.
But, as I said, you have to love the Roaming Buffalo. They’re very excited about their food, and everything is at least good, and the lamb is worth a trip. And the enthusiasm of the owners for their product communicates itself to the staff and makes all around for a very pleasant and memorable meal. If I were to go again, which isn’t really likely, I’d order the lamb shank plate with a side of sausage, and I’d probably try some of their chips.
Click “follow” on our front page to receive blog posts in your email box. Or bookmark us and check in from time to time. If you’re planning a trip, you can “Search” the name of the city, state, or country for good restaurants (in Europe, usually close to sites, like the Louvre or the Van Gogh Museum, that you’ll want to visit in any event). Comments, questions, and suggestions of places to eat or stories to cover are very welcome. And check out our Instagram page, johntannerbbq.