The Barbecue Center, Lexington, North Carolina

After a wonderful lunch with family at the Pit in Raleigh and a surprisingly good mid-afternoon meal at Rick’s Smokehouse, I drove on down to Salisbury and checked in to the local Courtyard Marriott. It’s a pleasant, clean, and healthy place. Based on my travels, Marriott is doing a fine job dealing with COVID.

I spent a couple of hours unpacking, deleting email messages, and trying desperately to unsubscribe from political emails, most of which addressed me as “Elizabeth” in the salutation. Then I drove back up to Lexington and went to the Barbecue Center.

I usually go to Lexington Barbecue #1, local known as the Honeymonk, for the simple reason that it is one of the world’s great barbecue places. There is, however, a substantial group of non-believers (barbecue, like Christianity and Marxism, is highly schismatic) who prefer the Barbecue Center. I’d been there before and liked it, but thought I should check it out again in the interests of journalistic integrity.

The Barbecue Center has a few spots for curb service, but they were full, so I went in to order. I will simply say that there ain’t much social distancing there. I ordered quickly, held my breath beneath my mask while waiting for my food, and went back to my car. I had ordered a pork and barbecued chicken (1/4 dark) combination plate with fried okra and red slaw. It came with some hushpuppies and a plastic container of the Barbecue Center’s dip (sauce).

As you can see, the plate also came with two packets of ketchup, the purpose of which mystified me for a minute. After due consideration, I took it as a personal affront: no right-thinking person would ever put ketchup on anything I ordered.

I opened the container as soon as I got into the car so that I could taste everything when it was fresh and hot. I had a good 20-minute trip back to the Courtyard, and I wanted to be fair to the food.

The chicken was good, nice and moist and flavorful, as dark meat usually is. And the fried okra was quite good. The pork was well cooked, but the sauce was entirely too sweet. It undermined the pork flavor. The slaw also was on the too-sweet side. It didn’t have that bite you usually get with fresh cabbage.

The hushpuppies were terrible. They were a touch overcooked, which I can live with, but they were mealy and crumbly. Did they leave out the egg? Cheat on the milk? I used some of the dip to wet them, but it didn’t really help. This was a big surprise. On my last trip, the hushpuppies were a big hit, good enough to raise my hushpuppy total for that day to 24. Had they been good, I would have set a new personal record.

My overall reaction was that Rick’s Smokehouse definitely was better, at least on that day. You may think that I’m being unfair, that I was put in a dyspeptic mood by the relative crowding in the Barbecue Center. Perhaps, although there could be no mistake about the hushpuppies. Or it may be that the Barbecue Center had an off day. Even great places have off days, or so I hear. Miss Myra’s had an off day once. Really. (The pit guy didn’t show up on a Game Day, when all of Alabama eats barbecue.) And a true ‘cue expert (who will remain nameless) recently told me that Grady’s can be uneven. Even Homer nods.

I hope — I expect, that this was just an off day for the Barbecue Center. I hope that those of you who go there will report back, and I hope those reports will reflect its recovered glory. Meanwhile, I’ll go to the Honeymonk or Rick’s — and I need to try Cook’s.


Click “follow” on our front page to receive blog posts in your email box.  Or bookmark us and check in from time to time.  If you’re planning a trip, you can “Search” the name of the city, state, or country for good restaurants (in Europe, often close to sites, like the Louvre or the Van Gogh Museum, that you’ll want to visit in any event).  Comments, questions, and suggestions of places to eat or stories to cover are very welcome.  And check out our Instagram page, johntannerbbq.

4 thoughts on “The Barbecue Center, Lexington, North Carolina

  1. Check out Garys in Chins Grove just down 85 from Salisbury

    On Fri, Oct 30, 2020 at 10:59 AM John Tanner’s Barbecue Blog wrote:

    > John Tanner posted: ” After a wonderful lunch with family at the Pit in > Raleigh and a surprisingly good mid-afternoon meal at Rick’s Smokehouse, I > drove on down to Salisbury and checked in to the local Courtyard Marriott. > It’s a pleasant, clean, and healthy place. Based on ” >

    Liked by 1 person

  2. When we lived in Charlotte, we always went to Wade Monk’s place on the way to Heaven, Chapel Hill. Before we discovered Lexington BBQ, we would stop at Tanner’s in Charlotte for sandwiches and Orange Drinks. I still stop in Lexington when traveling and have to bring bulk BBQ back with me. The hush puppies never make it back. Prior to Lexington, we would get BBQ and corn sticks from Parker’s. I have relatives in Bethel and they would always bring it when we had a family gathering. I like the Lexington BBQ much better, but Parker’s Corn sticks and Brunswick Stew were to Die for. I have eaten BBQ all over NC, western to eastern, and love it all. I never had bad BBQ until we moved to Atlanta 40 years ago. That heavy tomato based sauce is hard to take. Even the SC mustard stuff is better, and quite good on ribs. Now that BBQ is everywhere, I have no problem finding some. Rodney Scott opened a place in Atlanta, after I drove to Hemingway, SC to try it. It was worth the drive! I have a son that lives in Austin, TX and even they can produce some rather good BB (which is pork!). I love the smoked brisket, but it ain’t BBQ! The only good BBQ around Atlanta, is Williamson Brothers, their sauces are a bit thinner, less sweet and more spicy than many of the GA sauces. Now, Rodney Scott has a place here, Cracklin B’s, and one other I cannot remember at the moment have moved in and are very good. There’s a small shop near Emory U. called Community BBQ, that is quite good. Their smoked sweet potatoes with kale is one of my favorite sides now. Visit Atlanta some time!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. What a great comment! I see we have very similar tastes — animist of replaces you mention are reviewed on the blog — just search the name. You might try Heirloom Market in Atlanta (See post), and go to the Campaign for Real Barbecue web site Georgia page for some more tips. And I certainly hope to get back to Atlanta.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s